C140 crash at STOL competition

A Place to Share Experiences and Discuss Aviation Stories

Moderators: 6643, 6183, V529

Forum rules
You must be a member of the Cessna 120-140 Association in order to post new topics, reply to existing topics, or search for information on this forum. Use the "Join" link in the red menu bar.
6478
Posts: 59
Joined: Tue May 01, 2018 7:00 am
Location: Glendale, AZ
Name: Dean DeRosia
Aircraft Type: Cessna 140
Occupation-Interests:
Contact:

C140 crash at STOL competition

Post by 6478 »

It's a shame to follow the happiness of Dave's fresh overhaul with this tragic story. A C-140 crashed while on final at a STOL competition at KLCG Wayne, NE yesterday. Appears to have been a classic stall-spin. Fatal to a father of five. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K96RlzP ... nnel=Colbz
Dean DeRosia
N81L
1946 Cessna 140
Glendale, AZ KDVT
6478
Posts: 59
Joined: Tue May 01, 2018 7:00 am
Location: Glendale, AZ
Name: Dean DeRosia
Aircraft Type: Cessna 140
Occupation-Interests:
Contact:

Re: C140 crash at STOL competition

Post by 6478 »

N76075, out of California
Dean DeRosia
N81L
1946 Cessna 140
Glendale, AZ KDVT
6863
Posts: 130
Joined: Tue May 01, 2018 7:00 am
Location: EWK Newton, KS
Name: John Kliewer
Aircraft Type: C120
Occupation-Interests: Corporate PIlot - retired
Contact:

Re: C140 crash at STOL competition

Post by 6863 »

Very sad. Thank you for posting Dean. I heard about the accident this morning while eating breakfast at Beaumont KS but did not know the details. The video footage is graphic.

A good friend of mine reminded me today that just as the J-3 was once perceived as the safest airplane ever invented because it "can just barely kill you", so too is the low and slow of STOL competition. Having flown STOL operations for work as part of national infrastructures in Africa, not for play, I'm a bit jaded about these competitions having become the current entertainment rage and how they must certainly be perceived by many who enter them.

John
John Kliewer

"Make things as simple as possible but no simpler." Albert Einstiein

"Wheels move the body. Wings move the soul."
2066
Posts: 600
Joined: Tue May 01, 2018 7:00 am
Location: North Carolina
Name: Mac Forbes
Aircraft Type: '46 Cessna 140
Occupation-Interests: Retired - Current 120-140 Assoc. NC Rep.
Contact:

Re: C140 crash at STOL competition

Post by 2066 »

Photos now appearing of that beautiful young family surviving tugs at all of our hearts. Over a lot of years I've heard too many inquiries and conversations centering on attempts to re-make the 120/140/140A into something it was never intended to be. What Randy and a few others have accomplished with 0200 STCs helps extend the life of an excellent aircraft, very well designed for "low and slow"...but, not "lower, lower and slower and slower" & related competition, IMO. How painfully aware of that fact we are today. Your insight from genuine experience well taken, John. (Those of us too far from Beaumont to drop in for breakfast are envious, incidentally).
Mac
edidin
Posts: 139
Joined: Mon Jul 19, 2021 8:57 pm
Name:
Aircraft Type:
Occupation-Interests:
Contact:

Re: C140 crash at STOL competition

Post by edidin »

What a terrible tragedy. A 120/140 is not a STOL aircraft by any of the standards of the ridiculously low and slow aircraft in the contest. Seems like he was trying to maintain spacing behind one the of the 30 mph specialized aircraft and a 120 will not fly at that speed. Does beg the questions of why - a 120 has less hp and more wing loading than the various "super stop" birds seen in the video.
User avatar
6898
Posts: 307
Joined: Tue May 01, 2018 7:00 am
Location: IS65 Sandwich IL.
Name: Jeff T
Aircraft Type: 48 140 C90
Occupation-Interests: Auto,Marine&Aviation Repair
Contact:

Re: C140 crash at STOL competition

Post by 6898 »

Hearing the news while on a short camping trip. So tragic prayers with the family. A member of the Assoc. will be missed.
Jeff T 1948 C-140 NC3600V
Past President 120 140 Assoc. 2019-2023
User avatar
8434
Posts: 86
Joined: Wed Mar 27, 2019 3:27 am
Name: Marshall B
Aircraft Type: Cessna 140
Occupation-Interests:
Contact:

Re: C140 crash at STOL competition

Post by 8434 »

Very tragic. My condolences to his family. I heard about this right before heading out to a very backcountry airstrip, inaccessible by vehicle this time of year. It certainly made me think about the risks I am taking.

As for the Cessna 120/140 as a STOL plane: They aren't the best but that should be obvious. On one hand you have a plane designed in the 1940s for commuting, on the other a fully modified STOL specific aircraft. Its like go-carts vs F1. Anyone saying C140 has no business in STOL is saying no-one should race go-carts. The point here is you don't see a Go-cart on the F1 Circuit. As STOL comps gain larger audiences and more competitors hopefully we will see a Classic class where the sub 100hp aircraft are represented.

I often find myself flying my 140 alongside a 170B with a 180hp lyc and a CS prop, or a piper cruiser with a O360. Both out perform me by a large margin in the backcountry. I am constantly reminding myself that I should challenge my abilities but not in comparison to my buddies.
User avatar
simonlowther
Posts: 50
Joined: Sat Mar 20, 2021 10:32 pm
Location: New Zealand
Name: Simon Lowther
Aircraft Type: C120
Occupation-Interests: Airline pilot Airbus 320
Contact:

Re: C140 crash at STOL competition

Post by simonlowther »

8434 wrote: Mon May 23, 2022 10:27 am Very tragic. My condolences to his family. I heard about this right before heading out to a very backcountry airstrip, inaccessible by vehicle this time of year. It certainly made me think about the risks I am taking.

As for the Cessna 120/140 as a STOL plane: They aren't the best but that should be obvious. On one hand you have a plane designed in the 1940s for commuting, on the other a fully modified STOL specific aircraft. Its like go-carts vs F1. Anyone saying C140 has no business in STOL is saying no-one should race go-carts. The point here is you don't see a Go-cart on the F1 Circuit. As STOL comps gain larger audiences and more competitors hopefully we will see a Classic class where the sub 100hp aircraft are represented.

I often find myself flying my 140 alongside a 170B with a 180hp lyc and a CS prop, or a piper cruiser with a O360. Both out perform me by a large margin in the backcountry. I am constantly reminding myself that I should challenge my abilities but not in comparison to my buddies.
This is very well thought out and written; pretty much exactly sums up our little airplanes.

Si
Simon Lowther

Cessna 120 (11102)
a64pilot
Posts: 319
Joined: Sat Aug 29, 2020 8:41 pm
Name: Jody
Aircraft Type: C-140
Occupation-Interests: A&P former IA, Retired test pilot
Contact:

Re: C140 crash at STOL competition

Post by a64pilot »

I’ve heard people race lawnmowers.
Doesn’t mean it makes sense.

If you want to play STOL games, sell the 140 to someone who will take care of it and buy a kit fox or something.

These are old classic airplanes, they shouldn’t be torn up in such games. There are only just so many of them left.

I watched the video for what seemed 20 min and finally gave up, but the part I saw showed he plainly was in over his head, trying to the raise the tail, but bringing it down long before she was ready to fly and holding up elevator pushing the tailwheel into the ground, then trying the high deck angle on departure the other aircraft were doing, I expected to see a departure stall, he had to be right on the edge.

A 120/140 just simply is the wrong airplane. The reason you don’t see Mooney’s etc playing STOL games, I didn’t even see any 180’s, Maules etc, not even Supercubs, just the lightweight Rotax powered single seat no cargo types, in short something that likely as not arrived and left in a trailer and couldn’t do anything else but STOL
User avatar
8434
Posts: 86
Joined: Wed Mar 27, 2019 3:27 am
Name: Marshall B
Aircraft Type: Cessna 140
Occupation-Interests:
Contact:

Re: C140 crash at STOL competition

Post by 8434 »

I'd rather see a 140 in a STOL comp then left to rot in a field. Aviation is changing from a past time to a sport. A lot of new pilots want a reason to fly, and STOL comps give them that.

I look through my Journey logs, there was a five year period in the 70s that my bird only left the ground twice. To me that is far worse then playing STOL games.
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 10 guests